top of page

The Hidden Costs of Premature Spay and Neuter in Dogs: Health, Longevity, and Behavior

Spay and Neuter Guidelines from UC Davis on 40+ Dog Breeds
Spay and Neuter Guidelines from UC Davis on 40+ Dog Breeds

When it comes to the decision of spaying or neutering a dog, timing is everything. While vets have traditionally recommended early spay and neuter procedures, recent studies are shedding light on the potential downsides of this practice. At Constellation Canine Dog Training & Education, we advocate for a holistic and informed approach to dog care. Here, we delve into the potential health issues, impacts on longevity, and behavioral changes associated with premature spaying and neutering. Additionally, we explore alternative procedures that can offer benefits without some of the drawbacks.

Health Concerns

X-Ray Images of Canine Hips with and without Hip Dysplasia
X-Ray Images of Canine Hips with and without Hip Dysplasia

Orthopedic Issues

Research conducted by the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine reveals a link between early spay/neuter and an increased risk of orthopedic problems. Specifically, dogs that undergo these procedures before reaching physical maturity are more susceptible to hip dysplasia, cranial cruciate ligament tears, and other joint disorders. The absence of sex hormones during crucial developmental periods can affect bone growth and joint stability, leading to long-term health challenges.

Cancer Risks

Another significant concern is the increased risk of certain cancers. Studies, including those referenced by UC Davis, indicate that dogs spayed or neutered before one year of age may have a higher incidence of cancers such as lymphoma, hemangiosarcoma, and mast cell tumors. These findings highlight the protective role that sex hormones play in a dog's overall health, emphasizing the need to carefully consider the timing of these procedures.


Graph showcasing the Median Longevity of Dogs by Breed
Graph showcasing the Median Longevity of Dogs by Breed

Contrary to the common belief that spaying and neutering universally extend a dog's lifespan, evidence suggests that premature procedures might have the opposite effect. The UC Davis study points to a nuanced relationship between reproductive status and longevity, with some breeds experiencing shorter lifespans when altered early. For instance, Golden Retrievers spayed or neutered before one year of age were found to have shorter lifespans compared to those altered later or not at all.

Behavioral Changes

Behavioral implications of early spay or neuter are another critical aspect to consider. Hormones play a significant role in the development of social behaviors and emotional regulation in dogs. Premature alteration can sometimes lead to increased anxiety, fearfulness, and aggression. A study published in "Frontiers in Veterinary Science" highlights that neutered dogs showed a higher prevalence of undesirable behaviors compared to intact dogs. This underlines the importance of considering behavioral development when deciding the timing of these procedures.

The Dangers of Desexing Too Young

A particularly concerning trend is the increase in puppies being spayed or neutered prior to 8 weeks old, often seen in shelter settings. While the intention is to control the pet population and ensure that adopted pets cannot reproduce, this practice can set dogs up for failure as they grow and mature.

Growth Plate Closure Timeline for Large & Medium Breeds vs Toy & Small Breeds of Dogs
Growth Plate Closure Timeline for Large & Medium Breeds vs Toy & Small Breeds of Dogs

Physical Consequences

Puppies desexed at such a young age are at an even higher risk for the aforementioned orthopedic issues and cancer risks. Their bodies are deprived of the hormones necessary for proper growth and development, leading to stunted physical development and increased susceptibility to health problems.

Mental and Behavioral Impact

Early desexing can severely impact a dog's mental and emotional development. These dogs may exhibit increased fearfulness, anxiety, and aggression as they grow. Without the necessary hormones, their ability to regulate emotions and interact socially can be compromised, making them more challenging to train and manage.

The Sad Truth

Consider a shelter puppy spayed at 6 weeks old. As this dog matures, it may develop joint issues, leading to chronic pain and mobility problems. This could lead to potential behavioral outbursts, or being labeled as "stubborn" for refusing to sit or lay down on command due to pain. Behaviorally, it might struggle with anxiety and fear aggression, making it difficult for adopters to manage, and potentially making the dog unsafe. These challenges can lead to a higher likelihood of the dog being returned to the shelter, or facing a lower quality of life overall.

Alternatives to Traditional Spay and Neuter

For pet owners seeking to avoid the downsides of premature desexing, alternative procedures such as canine vasectomies and ovarian-sparing spays offer promising options.

Canine Vasectomy

A vasectomy allows a male dog to retain his testes, and thus, his hormones, while rendering him unable to reproduce. This procedure preserves the benefits of testosterone, including proper growth, bone density, and behavioral stability, without the risk of unwanted litters.

Ovarian-Sparing Spay

In an ovarian-sparing spay, the ovaries are left intact while the uterus is removed. This means the female dog retains her hormones, which are crucial for overall health, while eliminating the risk of pyometra (a life-threatening uterine infection) and preventing pregnancy. This procedure helps maintain the dog's natural hormone levels, supporting healthier physical and behavioral development.

Making an Informed Decision

As a dog owner, it is crucial to weigh the pros and cons of spaying or neutering at an early age. Here are some considerations to guide your decision:

- Consult with Your Veterinarian: Discuss the specific health and behavioral needs of your dog with your veterinarian. Each breed and individual dog can respond differently to early spay/neuter.

- Consider Breed-Specific Guidelines: Some breeds are more prone to the negative effects of early alteration. Research breed-specific recommendations to make an informed choice.

- Evaluate Health and Lifestyle Factors: Consider your dog's overall health, lifestyle, and any pre-existing conditions that might influence the timing of spay/neuter.

- Explore Alternatives: Ask your veterinarian about the possibility of a vasectomy or ovarian-sparing spay for your dog, and weigh the benefits these alternatives can provide.

Final Thoughts

The decision to spay or neuter your dog is a significant one that should not be made lightly. With growing evidence highlighting the potential downsides of premature procedures, it is essential to consider all aspects of your dog's health and development. By making an informed choice and exploring alternatives, you can help ensure your furry companion enjoys a long, healthy, and balanced life.

For more guidance on holistic dog training and care, visit Constellation Canine Dog Training & Education. Together, we can create a harmonious and fulfilling life for your beloved pet.


bottom of page